STAUPELL ANALYTICS GROUP - ANALYTICS EXPERTS FOR NONPROFITS, IMPROVING FUNDRAISING
  • Home
  • About
    • Staupell Team
    • Testimonials
    • Partnerships >
      • Prospect Research Institute
      • Lityx
      • TouchPoints
      • Gravyty
  • Services
    • Fundraising Analytics
    • Prospect Development
    • Business Intelligence
    • Database Administration
    • Fundraising Optimization Solution
  • Training
    • Analytics Machine Learning Artificial Intelligence
    • Business Intelligence Visualization Reporting
    • Prospect Research and Management
    • Webinars
    • Classes >
      • Beginner Analytics Using R
      • Analytics Classes
      • Skill Builder Series
    • Workbooks
  • Blog
  • Events
    • Water Cooler Chats
    • Video Replays
  • Contact
  • Product

Driven by Data Blog

Is This the End of Major Gifts?

9/2/2016

0 Comments

 
Major Gifts
I have recently returned from an AFP Central New York luncheon, hearing a talk given by Bill Abrams (of Infinize), and my mind can’t stop spinning about what Bill said. Let me share with you a boiled down version of his message:
As communication among humans gets faster and better, and as content and services become cheaper and/or free (think Uber over taxi and Skype over long distance phone calls), wealth and power will become more evenly distributed.
I interrupted Bill’s presentation to ask, “So, where will organizations’ major gifts prospects come from, then?” Bill answered that my local auto mechanic is much more likely to have as much income and wealth in the future as my banker does now – the Millionaire Next Door idea but cranked up several hundred RPMs.

And that’s when I started trembling, because now the number of prospects that my clients need to cultivate through personalized, special attention has gone from the top 5% of their constituency to – well – everyone. And I imagined major gifts programs melting down into a huge, stratified, boundless annual giving program.

This article shares my subsequent research along with some of Bill’s ideas to illustrate where this vision comes from.
Costs and Incomes Are Dropping

I don’t agree that the sharing economy is new. We’ve had centuries of families sharing assets -- such as the family car, the house, and the farm land -- for most of our existence. In addition, even celebrities like Carol Burnett participated in a sharing economy by living in a women’s dorm while she was building her career [1].

The difference is that we can share assets with strangers now. We don’t have to find people who are willing to give us a ride to the grocery store when our car is down – we can Uber over to the store or arrange for a Zip Car. So the efficiency of shared assets moves out of the family and into the entire world, and that is why Bill, in his presentation, showed us that neither the world’s largest taxi company (Uber), nor the world’s largest retailer (Alibaba), nor the world’s largest hotelier (Airbnb), nor the world’s largest media company (Facebook) has inventory. These companies offer information and access, not product.

Since cars, living spaces, and content can all be shared, we now need fewer cars, fewer hotels, and fewer subscriptions to television channels (see this Bloomberg Technology article on who’s fighting over taking control of our TVs). After all, if I can pick up a ZipCar on my way to an Airbnb reservation, then I need neither my own car nor a hotel room. And that is a threat to the companies that make cars and run hotels, to say nothing of how live streaming has taken away the monopoly that cable television used to have on us.

So our costs will get cheaper, but people who make cars, for instance, will also get thrown out of work. To illustrate this trend, Georgios Petropooulos’ article, “Uber and the Economic Impact of Sharing Economy Platforms,” shows a chart of Uber’s valuation overtaking the valuation of General Motors and Ford. This chart makes clear the impact of the sharing economy on our backbone manufacturing industry – cars.
Uber Valuation
With special thanks to the Bruegel company for allowing us to copy the chart in exchange for only this notice: Borrowed from, “Uber and the Economic Impact of Sharing Economy Platforms,” by Georgios Petrolpoulos, February 22, 2016.
And then there’s the economist Robert Gordon, who, on an episode of Freakonomics Radio told us that “the Second Industrial Revolution was a one-time event.” He goes on to say that growth in the near future will not be as rapid as it was when Rockefeller brought light to homes and made his fortune, or when trains were invented and whole industries were created. [2]

Gordon says that between 1870 and today, the standard of living has doubled, but forecasts our near future income growth to be 0.3 percent per year. Gordon says: “It means as many people will be falling back as those who are moving ahead.” [3]

Gordon’s hypothesis was supported in early 2016 when the Bank of Japan adopted negative interest rates. You get paid to borrow and you pay interest to save (see this Bloomberg QuickTake article for an explanation). This action is seen as desperation by countries trying to stimulate growth.

We have also seen many articles explaining how lower wage jobs (service industry jobs) have increased during our current recovery, and mid-and higher-wage jobs have disappeared (See this excellent article).

Are we heading toward a world of the very rich and the very poor? Many economists say yes, we definitely are. Bill’s presentation seemed to argue with that assumption.

Ultra-High Income Careers Will Dissipate

Part of Bill’s presentation was on the FIRE economy (see here for a good definition), which stands for:
  • Finance
  • Insurance
  • Real Estate
Professionals who work in this economy, as we can see from our research, have built their wealth through income in recent decades, as opposed to the old fashioned method of business ownership or inherited wealth as we had in the 1970s and 1980s.[4] A recent survey by US Trust (see here) noted that, of the 684 individuals surveyed for the report, 52% reported gaining their wealth through income.

The Capgemeni World Wealth Report for 2016 predicts that financial services, high tech, and healthcare are the top three industries that will drive growth in the wealth of our world’s ultra-high net worth individuals.

Bill’s presentation countered parts of that prediction when he discussed these new companies:
  • Prosper and Lending Club are peer-to-peer loan companies that bypass the finance companies altogether, offering cheaper loans.
  • Friendsurance and Lemonade are offering peer-to-peer insurance.
  • Zoominfo took some of the power away from real estate brokers.
  • Bitcoin is a tool for exchanging money across countries without a bank and with very low fees.
These disruptors, along with do-it-yourself software like TurobTax and Legal Zoom, will likely break the stronghold on income that our top one percent earners have. Consider what is happening to hedge fund managers, once the darlings of our major and principal gifts portfolios. The Guardian (see here) noted the “hedge fund killing field” on Wall Street but also mentioned that, “The world’s top 25 hedge fund managers earned $13bn last year – more than the entire economies of Namibia, the Bahamas or Nicaragua.” If Wall Street saw some hedge funds “lose billions of dollars and others to close down,” as the article says, then reduced income for these top-paid managers are surely to follow (my opinion).

So We Suggest…

Given this information, I can only wonder if an institution’s major gifts team, now working hard to solicit 95% of the organization’s gifts from 5% of its donors, will see a much more flattened prospect pool – more like a rectangle with strata of affinity and inclination rather than a pyramid with a narrow point at the top, representing the very few donors making the highest gifts. If the rising (or more democratic) tide raises all boats, though, I worry that fundraisers may drown in the subsequent high seas.

After all, in a fundraising shop, money and effort is spent on the very top prospects. If a shop finds that many more individuals have wealth to make gifts than the staff is accustomed to soliciting, even at more moderate giving levels, then the staff have a new responsibility to cultivate all of them with the same personal care and attention. And how could that be done?

Recently, the phenomenon of digital giving officers has emerged. Perhaps these professionals will recapture the attention of those whom we once called leadership annual giving prospects. Or perhaps many more constituents will be cultivated online.

We have also experienced the disruption of new technology in our own profession. Like it or not, our audience is online more and more, and that means that our old pattern of calling prospects on the phone asking for an in-person visit, can no longer be our only method of personal cultivation.  A recent Marketing Sherpa poll showed that people chose “phone call” as eighth among their preferred choices for hearing from a company, and e-mail was number one (see here). That preference held true across all age groups.
 
Many prospects now should be cultivated via LinkedIn and other social media, meaning that our gift officers must have an online presence. And online communities are springing up, forcing organizations to join in the electronic conversation.

A few years ago, I wondered where the next wave of new wealth would come from. I could not have thought that the wave of wealth would actually come from a wider segment of the current donor pool, and that wealth would be owned equally by both the hidden millionaire next door and the high-priced anesthesiologist on the other side of town. This is going to be interesting.

What are your thoughts on these changing conditions? Leave a comment below or tweet us @Staupell.

[1] See One More Time by Carol Burnett, published 1986 by Random House.

[2] Watch the series, The Men Who Built America, produced by the History channel to feel the impact of what Rockefeller, Carnegie, and Ford did for our lives and our economy.

[3] The Freakanomics Radio link will take you to the transcript of this show.

[4] From my personal experience as a prospect researcher during these decades.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Keep Informed
    Sign up for
    notifications when a
    new post comes out

    Sign Up Now


    Authors

    Marianne Pelletier has more than 30 years of experience in fundraising, with the majority in prospect research and prospecting.

    Greg Duke helps Raiser’s Edge clients to optimize their database by implementing data clean-up techniques and creating reporting structures, including dashboards and SQL queries.  He also facilitates data imports into Raiser’s Edge and database administration.

    Categories

    All
    Advancement Svcs
    Annual Giving
    Artificial Intelligence
    Assessment
    Big Data
    Blackbaud
    Branding
    Dashboards
    Databases
    Data Management
    Data Mining
    Data Prep
    Dependent Variables
    Donor Modeling
    Efficiency
    Engagement
    GDPR
    Giving Variables
    Linear Regression
    Machine Learning
    Major Gifts
    NFT
    Participation
    Productivity
    Project Planning
    Prospecting
    Prospect Research
    Push Technology
    Raiser's Edge
    RE NXT
    Reporting
    Research Pride
    RFM
    Statistics

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    March 2021
    September 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    July 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    December 2018
    September 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    September 2017
    June 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015

    View my profile on LinkedIn
Picture
© COPYRIGHT 2023 Staupell Analytics Group. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • Home
  • About
    • Staupell Team
    • Testimonials
    • Partnerships >
      • Prospect Research Institute
      • Lityx
      • TouchPoints
      • Gravyty
  • Services
    • Fundraising Analytics
    • Prospect Development
    • Business Intelligence
    • Database Administration
    • Fundraising Optimization Solution
  • Training
    • Analytics Machine Learning Artificial Intelligence
    • Business Intelligence Visualization Reporting
    • Prospect Research and Management
    • Webinars
    • Classes >
      • Beginner Analytics Using R
      • Analytics Classes
      • Skill Builder Series
    • Workbooks
  • Blog
  • Events
    • Water Cooler Chats
    • Video Replays
  • Contact
  • Product